A very strange and slightly random question, that has bothered me for some time.

[NotSoCheerios]

Nope.. they are an abomination.. KILL THEM!

but seriously.. I figure they would say.. in order to be safe.. they both go into a mental institution. One must suffer for the safety of the community.

[ARTgames]

Put the evil twin in a strait jacket and place them in a wheel chair and only give the controls to the good twin.

[Mr Pwnage]

Put the evil twin in a strait jacket and place them in a wheel chair and only give the controls to the good twin.

YES. And lets also put a muzzle over twin 2 so he can't speak/spit. Maybe even a blindfold and earplugs and nose-plugs which are all permanently fused to him.

[ARTgames]

To be honest i have no idea what your talking about. I cant tell if your being sarcastic and if you are not I'm not sure what flaw your point at. What did i miss?

[Mr Pwnage]

To be honest i have no idea what your talking about. I cant tell if your being sarcastic and if you are not I'm not sure what flaw your point at. What did i miss?

I was not being sarcastic. I am in full favor of using restraints and bondage devices on twin 2 so that twin 1 can proceed about his day freely.

[ARTgames]

Im sorry then. I was not sure.

[Red October]

I was not being sarcastic. I am in full favor of using restraints and bondage devices on twin 2 so that twin 1 can proceed about his day freely.

I would disagree, using bondage devices would encourage a master and slave relationship between the twins. In other words, the Judge would be sending Twin 2 into slavery. No Judge would order that punishment.

[Specialboy]

This is one of those cases where the death penalty comes in handy...  You can do surgery to seperate them, and the innocent ones gets the vital organs, and the murdering one doesn't.

[ARTgames]

I was not being sarcastic. I am in full favor of using restraints and bondage devices on twin 2 so that twin 1 can proceed about his day freely.

I would disagree, using bondage devices would encourage a master and slave relationship between the twins. In other words, the Judge would be sending Twin 2 into slavery. No Judge would order that punishment.

Well i don't think twin 1 can make twin 2 do forced labour being tied up and all. This is not any more slavery then going to jail.

Now if twin 2 could still use his hands and twin 1 had a shock collar that made twin 2 do what every twin 1 wanted then yea. But that's not what i was suggestion.

[Lingus]

This is one of those cases where the death penalty comes in handy...  You can do surgery to seperate them, and the innocent ones gets the vital organs, and the murdering one doesn't.

I think it has been mentioned that this is a hypothetical. And I believe in this hypothetical, there is no possibility of surgical separation. There are definitely plenty of complicated cases of conjoined twins that cannot be separated safely without putting both twins in danger. I think if there is even if the chance is low, a judge would not be able to make that decision. There's too much chance for a wrongful death suit. Better to have the innocent twin sit in jail with some form of compensation than to inadvertently kill him.

[Jackabomb]

What is the verdict for a similar murder committed by someone with split personality disorder?
I thought it would be somewhat similar.

[Mr Pwnage]

What is the verdict for a similar murder committed by someone with split personality disorder?
I thought it would be somewhat similar.

Well you'd probably send them to an insane asylum or something in that case. Though it really wouldn't be the same thing because the main issue here is that they are both sane people and we are trying to find a fair and just punishment for twin 2 with at the same time being reasonable to twin 1. Which is of course a rather hard verdict to reach...in any case though it wouldn't really be related?

[Aqua]

This is one of those cases where the death penalty comes in handy...  You can do surgery to seperate them, and the innocent ones gets the vital organs, and the murdering one doesn't.

That would be my verdict, and probably closest to the justice for both twins. But it'd be interesting to see what a real judge would say.

Also... Recently there were two Siamese twins conjoined at the hip, and sharing 1 kidney. A kidney donor was found, and they were separated, each with one leg... Hooray!
Question though... With just two legs... Wouldn't there be anatomical issues...? I'm serious.
~Aqua

[Scotty]

This is one of those cases where the death penalty comes in handy...  You can do surgery to seperate them, and the innocent ones gets the vital organs, and the murdering one doesn't.

That would be my verdict, and probably closest to the justice for both twins. But it'd be interesting to see what a real judge would say.

Also... Recently there were two Siamese twins conjoined at the hip, and sharing 1 kidney. A kidney donor was found, and they were separated, each with one leg... Hooray!
Question though... With just two legs... Wouldn't there be anatomical issues...? I'm serious.
~Aqua

Heads get's manhood, Tails gets nothing?

[Syco]

Kill them both...